A handful of communities across the country have attempted to and in many cases successfully enacted a series of immigration controls that stoke fear in Latino and immigrant communities. But a report from the Center for American Progress found that these communities spend millions of dollars defending these unconstitutional statutes in court. This drains strained budgets, depresses local economies, and divides communities along racial and ethnic lines.
A combination of factors have left immigrants as vulnerable scapegoats and spurred several communities to take federal immigration law into their own hands, including the fallout from the economic crisis and ensuing unemployment rates as well as inaction at the federal level on immigration reform.
The report makes clear that these local enforcement measures come with substantial costs that quickly add up. Arizona will see a loss of $388 million in economic output due to lost conferences and business meetings over the next two to three years due to its immigration law, S.B. 1070. The state is expected to lose $133 million in lost wages over the next two to three years due to the law. Farmers Branch, Texas has incurred more than $4 million since 2006 in legal fees to defend its anti-immigration statute, and Hazelton, Pennsylvania has spent $2.8 million defending its immigration control ordinance.
“Measures like these will bust your bank account,” said Angela Kelley, Vice President for Immigration Policy and Advocacy at CAP, in a press call in January. “Jurisdictions will spend substantial sums of money to pursue proposals that are in most cases going to lose in the courts.”
What’s more, local immigration enforcement measures can cause an exodus of immigrants from the town, which leads to loss of business and lost tax revenues. “When the buying power leaves the community and the small businesses lose that buying power and consumers, they close and the home foreclosures become exacerbated,” said Prince William County, Virginia supervisor Frank Principi, explaining the effects of a local ordinance Prince William adopted in 2007.
But that’s not all. Local immigration measures also have heavy social costs. Laws that target immigrants create deep racial divisions within communities that can take many years to overcome. Tomball, Texas shelved a proposal to make English the official language due to the divisions such a measure would create.
A recent report from the Southern Poverty Law Center, or SPLC, explains that these anti-immigrant ordinances have roots in the Nativist ...
Deportee Chronicles: Life after diesel therapy
Editor’s note: The second in a series of articles about the lives of U.S. deportees living in Mexico.
Fernando Santos’ life these days doesn’t exactly fit his old nickname: “Drifter.” Instead of wandering the land, the former U.S. resident takes care of others who answer the call of the road at ...
After parents' deportation, children face mental struggles
Cover: Artist Jason Zepeda and La Mina Circle created “50 Butterflies & 11 Millions Stripes” featuring 11 stripes representing 11 million living in the shadows, 50 butterflies for 50 states where migrant people have resided, reside, or will reside. Zepeda is a founding member of La Mina Circle, ...
Finding hope in “The State of Arizona”
For filmmakers Catherine Tambini and Carlos Sandoval, another film focused on immigration was not in the cards. Ten years ago they made the award-winning documentary, “Farmingville” about immigration in America set against the backdrop of the murder of two Latino day laborers. The film was a ...
Cuban students to benefit by historical effort
Danilo Maldonado (featured on cover) is a graffiti artist from Cuba and one of the 15 students from Cuba studying at Miami Dade College under a student visa. He's better known as “El Sexto” (The Sixth) the name he uses to sign his artwork.
A professor switches between English and Spanish as he ...